Our board game ratings are based on 3 very simple criteria. Yes, during reviews we will talk about mechanics, artwork/theme, playtime, etc.
But in the end, it is the below criteria that makes a great game for us:
Of course, these are our opinions and everyone has different tastes. Currently our tastes are weighted towards light to medium complexity games. Our gaming partners are our grade school children so we can’t wade in too deep into the water just yet. We do like heavy games as well . . . when we have the time to play them.